Culinary

What’s the Role of Today’s Executive Chef in Private Clubs?

The-Role-of-Today's-Executive-Chef-in-Private-Clubs

When hiring, committees are choosing a person first. Exceptional chefs, leaders, and mentors know how to attract talented individuals with diverse strengths. One of the greatest skills for Executive Chefs is keeping pace with the industry’s rapid changes and the wealth of information available to their members.

According to the Harvard Business Review, as information continues to double approximately every seven years, educational institutions are equipping graduates to retrain themselves multiple times throughout their careers. These considerations indicate that the hospitality industry will continue to push its boundaries. Our nation’s history has not seen a period more dynamic for professionals within this field. The public increasingly expects innovative culinary interpretations, distinctive entertainment concepts, and consistent energy when engaging in the art of dining.

Certain principles remain constant: mastering your craft, understanding cooking techniques, and knowing the science behind ingredient interactions. Additionally, fundamental human values such as ethics, morals, and interpersonal engagement are governed by established norms. As an Executive Chef, it is important to recognize that your team operates under your vision while also seeking personal satisfaction in their roles. Effective leadership involves supporting your staff, who, in turn, provide service to the members.

Executive Chefs frequently encounter a variety of complex challenges that invite them into broader discussions. These shifts often stem from political influences and the need to navigate global policies and leadership decisions at both the state and national levels within our democratic system. While maintaining member satisfaction remains a primary responsibility for chefs, it is essential to consider how these changes impact their roles and overall operations.

A professional commitment to respecting raw materials encompasses ethical harvesting from our oceans, careful management of growth cycles, consideration of organic practices, and adherence to responsible bio-genetic principles. As Auguste Escoffier wisely stated, “The handling and care of the raw product is 50% of the preparation.” Addressing biogenetics, genetically modified organisms (GMOs), and food safety requires expertise in proper supply labeling and transparent communication rather than political positioning.

The relentless curiosity for technology and methods will propel us professionally without compromising our culinary artisanal traditions. We need to discover innovative ways to showcase, produce, and deliver our craft. Many club kitchens struggle with consistency, often because Executive Chefs hesitate to allocate capital budgets for better solutions. This is evident when I tour new kitchens that do not have the most modern cooking systems because the existing chef would rather have traditional ovens. Escoffier himself was innovative, or he would not have placed recipes into a book.

Human forgiveness and an appreciation for political boundaries, emerging economies, and cultural diversity are crucial as we strive to meet the nutritional needs of global populations. As M.F.K. Fisher stated, “The world was discovered in our curiosity and search for foods.” In today’s workforce, diversity remains prevalent, and organizations that embrace it tend to achieve stronger staffing outcomes.

Your leadership will be challenged to inspire people to grow, secure a clear vision, initiate action in others, energize results, and maintain a commitment to common goals. This is the leadership that will take our culinary profession into the new millennium. Classic quotes such as, “Don’t ask—that’s how the Chef wants it,” or the even more traditional, “The Chef is always right,” are endearing comments to many, but they are, in fact, holding our profession back. We must move our kitchens forward with progressive communication and empathy.

Your dedication in the roles of educator, teacher, and mentor will significantly influence the methodologies applied in future years. As Food and Wine pioneer Robert Mondavi expressed, “Tell me and I will forget. Show me and I will remember. Teach me and I understand.”

It is essential to demonstrate a genuine passion for excellence within our profession while presenting your achievements with humility and acknowledging the successes of our industry. Strive to develop the next culinary innovation, as demonstrated by the leaders in this field. These demanding responsibilities characterize the role of an outstanding Executive Chef.

If this seems unreasonable, then you are in the right place. Every professional position must be overwhelming with change, or the industry to which you belong is not growing. If there is no growth, then it dissolves. Having challenges is the reward for success, and this propels the profession forward with a clear and healthy future.

Club + Resort Chef – May 2026

Lawrence T. McFadden, CMC, ECM is a food and beverage training consultant and search executive with KOPPLIN KUEBLER & WALLACE, a consulting firm providing executive search, strategic planning and data analysis services to the private club and hospitality industries.

What’s the Role of Today’s Executive Chef in Private Clubs?2026-06-01T20:18:39+00:00

How Heavily Does Atmosphere Affect Diner Satisfaction?

How-Heavily-Does-Atmosphere-Affect-Diner-Satisfaction

What if our satisfaction with food quality is influenced by factors like atmosphere, noise level, dress code, and technology? Just as families have different preferences when choosing a restaurant, club members do, too. Around the dinner table, perceptions of quality—and even appetite—can vary from person to person. My dad used to say, “Can I just eat in peace?” whenever things got too noisy at dinner.

Successful organizations understand their customers and their preferences. Chefs recognize that consistency and popular menu items foster loyalty. The pandemic affected ingredient costs, staffing levels, and safety protocols through technology. Although conditions won’t return to how they were, some strategic changes have been overly drastic.

Society’s casual attitude began forming as early as 2000 for us at the Ritz. At a lobby table, an elderly couple in seersucker sat across from a young tech entrepreneur in a hoodie, while others entered wearing hip-hop-inspired baggy jeans and glittery sneakers. The shift in our restaurant was evident even then. Despite attempts to enforce dress codes, once seated, guests revealed their preferences and personalities.

Most club memberships average between 55 and 65 years old, spanning three-plus generations. Many are Baby Boomers, who hold the greatest wealth among members. Baby Boomers have voiced strong concerns over new restaurant practices like QR code menus and digital wine lists. When QR code menus swept through restaurants during the pandemic, the logic made sense: physical menus were a contact risk, smartphones were universal, and going digital seemed like a clean solution. Safety and comfort were priorities. Yet two-thirds of consumers aged 60-plus are uncomfortable using technology, according to industry surveys. The surprise today is how broadly that feeling has spread.

In 2024, even tech-savvy Gen Z showed a strong preference for tangible menus, with around 90% favoring print. Club locations such as pools or golf areas that are fully digital are now facing a member engagement problem. While staffing and service delivery times have improved with technology, not all members are happy navigating another device.

With technology comes digital devices such as TVs and other noise-producing elements in dining rooms. Walk into almost any trendy, remodeled club today, and the first thing you notice isn’t the smell of food—it’s the noise level. Hard floors, open ceilings, exposed brick, and display kitchens pushed into the center of dining rooms have turned dinner into something that can genuinely strain your hearing. Long gone are the sound-buffering elements of carpet, drapes, cloth-stuffed chairs, and the classic ’70s drop ceilings. Last week, I was in Florida at a beautifully designed new space, yet the GM mentioned they needed to add sound baffling.

While a higher noise level may feel more current and exciting for some members, it is more than an annoyance—it is a genuine barrier. I remember eating with my dad when he got his first set of hearing aids; he was so distracted in hard-surfaced spaces. The World Health Organization estimates that 60% of adults aged 60 and older will experience moderate or greater age-related hearing loss. If a member is distracted, how can they emotionally engage with the waiter’s description, fellow diners, or the comfort of the dining space?

Studies by dining guide Zagat reveal that noise levels are the top complaint among diners, ranking ahead of bad food, slow service, and high prices as the factor most likely to ruin a meal. Dress code violations are never as offensive as someone at the next table speaking loudly or having a cell phone conversation.

Boomers—my age group—are the least comfortable generation when it comes to restaurant technology and are the most skeptical about the use of AI. According to DoorDash’s 2025 Trends Report, only 34–40% of boomers are comfortable with AI recommendations, compared to much higher percentages among younger generations.

Millennials and Gen Z are more inclined to embrace digital tools for dining, loyalty programs, and real-time promotions, while boomers and Gen X prefer a more traditional approach mixed with modern conveniences. The frustration isn’t simply about not understanding technology—it’s about what gets lost when screens replace staff. Nearly 90% of survey respondents said their main reason for eating out was to spend time with family and friends, and a dining room full of people staring at phone screens or tablet kiosks works directly against that purpose.

Many clubs that initially adopted digital menus have returned to physical menus or now use a combination of both, especially in casual settings like pools or grab-and-go areas. Most members continue to favor a traditional, human-centered dining experience. Member interactions are also the primary reason employees remain at a particular club, making these connections valuable for everyone involved. As a relationship-oriented species, humans communicate a great deal through nonverbal cues.

As a Baby Boomer, I once thought getting older meant simply wanting more silence—until I read that in 2023, SoundPrint found that over half of dining spaces were so loud that it was difficult to have a conversation. These are not niche complaints from a resistant audience; they represent the dominant feedback shaping how the industry is adjusting heading into 2026. Designers of restaurant spaces need to create more zone-based environments because society isn’t going to start speaking more quietly.

Club + Resort Chef – May 2026

Lawrence T. McFadden, CMC, ECM is a food and beverage training consultant and search executive with KOPPLIN KUEBLER & WALLACE, a consulting firm providing executive search, strategic planning and data analysis services to the private club and hospitality industries.

How Heavily Does Atmosphere Affect Diner Satisfaction?2026-05-06T21:34:19+00:00

Lawrence McFadden, CMC, 2026 C+RC Hall of Fame Inductee

Lawrence-McFadden-2026-Hall-of-Fame-Inductee

Lawrence McFadden’s career reflects a rare combination of technical mastery, global influence, and executive leadership that has helped broaden the definition of what a chef can become.

As a Certified Master Chef through the American Culinary Federation, McFadden achieved one of the most demanding distinctions in the culinary profession. Fewer than one hundred chefs in American history have earned the title, which represents sustained excellence in technique, discipline, and performance under pressure. It is a designation that signals both mastery of the craft and a commitment to advancing its standards.

His professional foundation was built at The Greenbrier, where classical training and competitive rigor established the discipline that would define his career. During that time, he earned a place on the U.S. Culinary Olympic Team, representing the United States among the world’s leading culinarians.

Over more than four decades, McFadden held leadership roles across globally recognized hospitality organizations including The Ritz-Carlton Company, MGM Grand Hotel and Casino, Shangri-La Hotels, and the Waldorf Astoria. His appointment as the first American Corporate Chef for The Ritz-Carlton Company marked an important moment in the evolution of global culinary leadership, as he helped shape menu development, training systems, and operational standards across an international portfolio of luxury properties.

His work consistently bridged culinary excellence with organizational leadership. In corporate roles with MGM Resorts and Shangri-La Hotels, McFadden helped guide complex food and beverage programs across multiple properties and markets, influencing hospitality experiences on a global scale. His contributions extended beyond execution to include systems development, leadership training, and operational strategy.

Education and mentorship have remained central themes throughout his career. As owner of Sunrice GlobalChef Academy in Singapore, he helped shape curriculum and professional training standards for emerging culinarians representing multiple regions and culinary traditions. His work reinforced the importance of structure, discipline, and technical fundamentals as the foundation for long-term professional growth.

McFadden later brought his experience into the private club environment, serving as General Manager and Chief Operating Officer of The Union Club of Cleveland. In that capacity, he demonstrated how culinary professionals can evolve into enterprise leaders responsible for governance, financial stewardship, and organizational culture (See “The Master Chefs of Cleveland’s Union Club“). His leadership was recognized with the Mel Rex Excellence in Club Management Award, a national honor acknowledging outstanding achievement in private club leadership.

Today, he continues to contribute to the profession through mentorship, advising, writing, and thought leadership that challenge chefs to think more broadly about standards, accountability, and the evolving role of culinary leadership.

Across each stage of his career, McFadden has demonstrated that culinary expertise can serve as a foundation for broader leadership. His work has influenced luxury hospitality brands, educational institutions, private clubs, and the professionals who lead them.

Club + Resort Chef – April 2026

Lawrence T. McFadden, CMC, ECM is a food and beverage training consultant and search executive with KOPPLIN KUEBLER & WALLACE, a consulting firm providing executive search, strategic planning and data analysis services to the private club and hospitality industries.

Lawrence McFadden, CMC, 2026 C+RC Hall of Fame Inductee2026-04-27T16:27:36+00:00

How Long Should You Stay at Your Club?

How-Long-Should-You-Stay-at-Your-Club-McFadden

Even after living in 12 different places and holding 15 different positions, I still found myself afraid of change. Yet what scares me even more is the idea of becoming institutionalized. I often wonder whether I am truly moving forward or simply running from something. In my first corporate job, before airplanes offered wifi, executives joked that staying in the air made you harder to hold accountable. This attitude reflected a lack of real ownership in understanding the company’s success.

Sous chefs face constant challenges and expectations to keep our careers moving forward. We refine our culinary and leadership skills under various chefs, collecting experiences and celebrity mentors like trophies. Committees that lack an understanding of strategic culinary career development often focus primarily on these well-known industry figures. Throughout my transitions, I frequently asked myself whether I was genuinely seeking improvement in my abilities or simply pursuing better outcomes. My journey took me through clubs, hotels, standalone restaurants, and different regions across the United States. Eventually, I found my niche in the luxury resort sector, where I spent most of my professional career.

Talent creates opportunities but can also produce professional insecurity. High-risk takers tend to focus on future possibilities, while risk-averse leaders prefer to remain grounded in the present, often solving problems themselves rather than delegating. At one point, we hired a Director of Food and Beverage who had held several roles at different organizations for less than two years each. On the surface, she appeared to be steadily advancing. Her mentor had advised her to spend only 18 to 24 in each role, gain experience, and then move on. I observed, however, that leaders who change positions too frequently rarely take full ownership of projects or see them through to completion. They also miss the confidence that comes from witnessing positive results over time. I encouraged this young leader to pause, evaluate, and commit to our club for a longer period. To our mutual benefit, she stayed for five years, grew professionally, and saw numerous projects completed. Her development centered on making meaningful contributions rather than simply holding titles within our small club.

This raises an important question: What is the right amount of time to stay with an organization, and how much loyalty is expected?

Large brands often allow employees to relocate without losing a sense of loyalty to the organization. Clubs, however, may view frequent moves as unreliable—especially for executive chefs compared to sous chefs. In China, kitchen staff often work together for long periods, with the head chef acting almost like a union representative and maintaining consistency in hiring. Committees frequently ask whether an executive chef will bring their own team. I always bring a trusted sous chef to ensure efficiency. Many committees want rapid change while retaining the entire existing staff, which can sometimes contradict the mission.

Clubs invest significantly in executive chefs, valuing both their expertise and their loyalty. It is important to consider what clubs expect in return for the salaries they offer. While people work for people, chefs should also recognize their professional responsibilities within the industry. Leaving a club too soon can negatively affect future candidates and undermine the commitments made at the start of employment.

Young executive chefs should expect to stay at least three years, with five years often considered ideal. Short tenures can raise doubts about decision-making, especially after two or three quick transitions. Large brands may request relocation to different properties, but higher compensation often comes with greater expectations of loyalty. Talent matters, but tenure matters as well. Hiring managers and general managers must carefully evaluate candidates who move too frequently, as repeated transitions affect operational stability.

Risk deserves recognition, particularly when changing roles or relocating. When a young chef resigned, I congratulated them out of respect for their courage. I never attempted to persuade them to stay or offered a promotion as a countermeasure. Leadership should recognize that a two-week notice primarily serves the employer, not the employee. Aside from retirement or long-term service, concluding the relationship efficiently can sometimes benefit everyone involved.

This philosophy differs from traditional succession planning or mentorship. In Florida, each season we evaluated and planned the next role or strategy for every kitchen leader. By taking a proactive approach, we prepared for the future alongside our chefs. When we developed growth plans for them, they recognized that we were investing in their careers—even before new opportunities appeared. Crafting these succession plans also strengthened my own commitment to staying. Taking calculated risks is often necessary for leaders to seize new opportunities, though some individuals are more comfortable with risk than others. The same applies to you.

Club + Resort Chef – April 2026

Lawrence T. McFadden, CMC, ECM is a food and beverage training consultant and search executive with KOPPLIN KUEBLER & WALLACE, a consulting firm providing executive search, strategic planning and data analysis services to the private club and hospitality industries.

How Long Should You Stay at Your Club?2026-04-23T19:50:49+00:00

Living Your Autobiography

Living-Your-Autobiography-Executive-Chefs

Some of the greatest things we said or did, we never knew we said or did. The older you get, the more that statement is shared with you. As a youth, I had nothing to add to the conversation, and so respectfully, my mom would ask that I listen—a great muscle memory practice that I still use today. A close friend of thirty years once commented, “Lawrence, you have always been reserved in your comments, but when you do say something, I learn.”

Reading and writing are among the most valuable gifts available to us. Aside from work-related reading, I also read to learn, and I approach writing the same way. Just as steps tracked on your phone don’t necessarily lead to better health, reading simply to react or complete a task isn’t the same as reading to gain knowledge. Now that I’m older, I wake up earlier and do most of my reading and writing between 5 and 7 in the morning. During these hours, my mind is sharp, the surroundings are peaceful, and my thoughts are more focused. Each morning, I turn to two favorite books, Spiritual Leadership and Tao Te Ching, reading a few pages from each.

I’ve spent eight years writing for Club and Resort Chef, after six years previously journaling in Asia. Sometimes I worry about relevance or being over-published, but my writing has helped me gain perspective beyond culinary and club life. It improves the questions I ask myself and others, and these skills are strengthened by serving members and meeting exceptional people at sister clubs. Most mentors, parents, and siblings I’ve encountered read, write, or exercise for brain health.

Each article receives heartfelt messages, sometimes even months later during future club visits. General Managers frequently express gratitude for insights into kitchens—an area that can feel unfamiliar and even intimidating to them. As one GM noted, knowing someone well reduces misunderstanding, while distance in relationships breeds it. Building these relationships requires genuine effort to understand and connect in both the kitchen and the GM’s office.

When I read or listen to something, the words often resonate with me differently. In many spiritual traditions, recitation or meditation is used to internalize beliefs. At Ritz-Carlton, this is called “lineup,” where we recited our daily credo, the daily basis, and the employee promise. Over time, these words become part of our beliefs, offering comfort and a sense of shared purpose.

Change starts with personal action. While words matter, actions have more impact. The way we behave—through our habits, attire, and values—influences others in any organization. At Ritz-Carlton, leadership was often passion-driven, while Marriott’s was more restrained, though both valued wisdom and intelligence, expressed in different ways that reflected distinct cultures. Executive chefs often face tension between traditional training and modern productivity. What once felt team-oriented may now seem outdated. Learning from diverse sources helps refine your vision and keep your approach relevant. These lessons come through continued reading and learning from others.

Recently, I attended a presentation by a respected colleague on the topic of delegation. With nearly 30 years of culinary experience, he addressed an audience that included both emerging chefs and seasoned professionals nearing retirement. His message was likely received in a variety of ways, influenced by differing perspectives and mindsets. This diversity of response is particularly relevant to my blog, as I have observed comments appearing sporadically—sometimes after several articles—that indicate that, at certain moments, my content has resonated with readers. Positive engagement, such as appreciation for kindness, tends to foster a sense of community, while negativity can lead to division. Many organizations say culture is important, but their actions—or the frequency with which they discuss it—suggest otherwise.

When I write, I value generating my own ideas. This makes AI helpful for basic editing but risky for creative expression or personal storytelling. Using tools like Copilot for projects left me unsatisfied because it took away the satisfaction of original thought—the dopamine hit of creativity. Relying too heavily on AI is like chefs copying cookbooks; it prevents authentic growth. In leadership, following is necessary to learn, but taking risks leads to true personal reward. While AI is useful for certain routine tasks, depending on it for creativity can undermine authenticity. Like all tools of communication—email, the web, and now AI—the output reflects the interpretation of the individual author.

Throughout my career, the most impactful conversations have primarily taken place verbally rather than through written communication such as email or text. Over time, my focus has shifted significantly; I now value the company I dine with more than the meal itself—a notable change from when my attention was solely on food, regardless of companions. When peers remark, “Lawrence, that was the best thing I ever ate,” I often ask, “Did you share it with your mother?” This question reflects the evolution described in my professional autobiography.

As an Executive Chef, I once viewed dining as an avenue for research and development. Today, it serves as an opportunity to connect with and listen to others. It is important for committee members to recognize that their perception of food may differ from that of their chef. Both perspectives are valid, and practicing empathy—seeking to understand before being understood—is fundamental to effective collaboration. What is not said can also be a valuable tool for those with high emotional intelligence.

Club + Resort Chef – April 2026

Lawrence T. McFadden, CMC, ECM is a food and beverage training consultant and search executive with KOPPLIN KUEBLER & WALLACE, a consulting firm providing executive search, strategic planning and data analysis services to the private club and hospitality industries.

Living Your Autobiography2026-04-22T18:45:22+00:00

Your Communication Will Always Define Your Success

Your-Communication-Will-Always-Define-Your-Success-in-Private-Club-Kitchens

A client once remarked on how calm I appeared, a contrast to my earlier, more energetic leadership style. Having spent the first 20 years of my career as a chef, I understood that challenges appeared within minutes, not days, and there is little room for pause or quiet. Decisions often had to be made in 30 seconds—right or wrong. Safety was always crucial, especially when supervising a young cook working with hot oil, open flames, or powerful mixers. There was rarely time to sit back and wait for an epiphany. Instead, an excellent chef stayed on the balls of their feet, moving quickly, anticipating needs, and sometimes raising their voice in the name of safety. What we called coaching involved predicting problems and making rapid corrections.

Interview committees frequently ask candidates about their weaknesses during the selection process. Common questions focus on feedback from recent performance reviews and areas where improvement may be needed. I often reflect on how I would answer such questions and what responses would resonate with a selection committee. Successful interviewing requires practice, a skill rarely taught outside formal education. As my experience and leadership responsibilities grew, several areas of my communication had to improve in order to reach future opportunities. Self-development is always an individual choice, and those who embrace it grow.

Response to Negativity

Early in my culinary career, I struggled with negativity—not only in how I responded to criticism, but also in how I processed disappointment when others disliked my food or interactions. A predictive index assessment confirmed that criticism was difficult for me, despite choosing a profession centered on customer opinion and preference.

This reality became clear throughout my culinary career. Later, when I transitioned into front-of-house leadership, I was no longer personally preparing the food. The experience felt less personal and emotional, and connecting with guests became another dimension of the dining experience. Food evokes strong emotions, which shape preferences and play a central role in how people experience a meal.

Delivery of My Message

During the second phase of my leadership development, the delivery of my feedback required improvement. Although my intentions were positive, employees often misinterpreted my message. Communication relies heavily on tone and body language, not just words. My direct approach sometimes came across as curt, and I occasionally behaved in ways that I would not have considered professional.

I once followed the advice of a respected mentor who said, “When I stop giving you feedback, it means I have stopped caring about your growth.”

At times, my communication also included inappropriate language and profanity. While these habits developed unintentionally, they created a perception that did not align with expectations for public leadership communication. As a result, several colleagues raised concerns about my readiness for advancement to the next level of leadership.

Many strong leaders encounter this social challenge. It can hinder career progress because they assume their previous methods are sufficient. However, outstanding leaders often recognize that adapting and evolving their approach contributes more to long-term success than intelligence or personal opinion alone.

Perception of Being Aloof or Dismissive

After several years working in Asia, colleagues and team members began to comment on my reserved demeanor and, at times, perceived aloofness. Some questioned my lack of eye contact or facial engagement during conversations, particularly when our viewpoints differed. I had developed a habit of closing my eyes or focusing on a fixed point while listening, which helped me concentrate more deeply—almost like a subtle form of meditation amid surrounding noise. This behavior was eventually noticed by one of my presidents and discussed during an annual review.

After reading the quote, “Your opinion of me is none of my business,” I began to understand the importance of focusing on strengthening my own confidence. Many people worry about how others judge them and try to change those perceptions. Yet those opinions are not facts; they belong to others. It is more productive to remain focused on positive intentions and continued improvement.

My experience working with Chinese colleagues reinforced the importance of accuracy in statements, clarity in communication, and concise delivery. During my tenure with an Asian organization, I learned to speak only when invited, which greatly strengthened my listening skills and contributed significantly to my professional development.

After every professional conversation, I reflect on what I intended to communicate, what I actually conveyed, and what I wish I had articulated differently. This practice reinforces the understanding that perfection is unattainable in human interaction and encourages a commitment to continuous learning. These communication blind spots directly influence leadership and shape one’s professional image. Popular culture has created a certain image of chefs, and it is our responsibility as leaders to reshape that image into a more thoughtful and successful one.

Club + Resort Chef – March 2026

Lawrence T. McFadden, CMC, ECM is a food and beverage training consultant and search executive with KOPPLIN KUEBLER & WALLACE, a consulting firm providing executive search, strategic planning and data analysis services to the private club and hospitality industries.

Your Communication Will Always Define Your Success2026-03-26T21:54:47+00:00
Go to Top